← late night stories

The trauma as content

30 Sep 2026

I have no issue with people talking about what hurt them. Quite the opposite. What troubles me is harder to pin down: the confession, once shared with someone we trusted, has started to take a shape dictated by the medium, not the speaker.

Critic Catherine Liu, in a 2023 essay for Noema, describes a standardized pattern sociologist Eva Illouz calls the "trauma narrative": an innocent protagonist is shattered, then reassembled as a survivor. When I read it, I recognized something I’d seen but lacked the words for. The stories begin and end almost the same way, as if molded from a template. It strikes me that what makes a story easy to spread—its recognizability—is also what makes it less personal. I’m stating this as an impression, not a proven fact.

Trauma as a category, of course, wasn’t born on social media. Liu reminds us that modern ideas about it began in the 19th century, in legal and medical debates over “railway spine”—who was to blame when a train accident left someone with nervous symptoms. Later, the inclusion of post-traumatic stress disorder in the DSM-III in 1980 came through psychiatrist Robert Jay Lifton’s advocacy for Vietnam veterans, and Judith Herman’s book gave a similar framework to sexual violence. These were real victories. People who no one believed gained a language and recognition. But they also show that trauma has always been tied to institutions, compensation, and validation. Didier Fassin and Richard Rechtman, in The Empire of Trauma (2009), describe it as a moral language through which the victim is acknowledged.

In the public sphere, the shift from the private to spectacle is nothing new. Liu notes that Oprah Winfrey spoke in 1986 about the sexual abuse she experienced as a child, and that in 2021 she co-created the series The Me You Can’t See on Apple TV+ with Prince Harry, where celebrities discuss their own experiences. I’m not judging anyone’s sincerity, and I don’t think it can be judged from a distance. My question is different: when a confession is also part of a public image, how do you separate one from the other? Maybe there’s no need to. But I rarely see the question even asked.

Platforms and what they do with all this is something Liu has a clear take on, and it’s worth noting it’s hers alone: she argues that trauma narratives have been leveraged to turn mental health into something shared and processed collectively online, for the commercial benefit of the platforms. Shoshana Zuboff, in The Age of Surveillance Capitalism (2019), has shown that their model relies on harvesting behavioral data, and mental distress is data like anything else. The most tangible example I found is BetterHelp. In 2023, the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) accused the online counseling platform of sharing sensitive data with Facebook and Snapchat for advertising purposes, and the company agreed to pay $7.8 million. To be fair, BetterHelp didn’t admit guilt and says it didn’t share names or clinical session data. The case is about data, not narratives. It just shows that mental health information has commercial value.

There’s also a more mundane problem: the quality of information. In 2025, the Guardian asked psychiatrists and psychologists to evaluate the 100 most popular TikTok videos tagged with #mentalhealthtips. The experts found that 52 contained some form of misinformation, while many others were vague or useless. Among the issues were the misuse of therapeutic terms and promises that trauma could be “healed” in just a few hours. It’s a journalistic investigation with a panel of experts, not a published scientific study, and the sample is small. The conclusion I can draw is cautious: the most visible content isn’t necessarily the most reliable. Frank Furedi had already written in 2004, in Therapy Culture, about how therapeutic language is spreading into more and more aspects of life, and thirty-second videos seem like the latest iteration of that trend.

There’s also a deeper explanation, which I partly agree with. Liu says trauma culture fills a gap in access to mental healthcare: private sessions are expensive, insurance coverage is limited, and it’s no surprise some people seek meaning in celebrities and social media. In Capitalist Realism (2009), Mark Fisher calls this the "privatization of stress": a pain with social causes is framed as an individual problem to be solved individually. Liu’s political conclusion—that mental health needs to be socialized—is an opinion, not a fact, and anyone who disagrees is entitled to do so. But the observation about access is hard to ignore.

I know I’m not the first to say this. In 2021-22, Parul Sehgal in The New Yorker and Will Self in Harper’s had already written about fatigue with the "trauma narrative." Liu criticizes them for focusing on aesthetic issues. I don’t know if she’s right. What I do know is that I can’t prove anyone’s motives. I can’t say influencers repeat their pain for engagement because I haven’t seen it documented, and I’m not claiming public discussion hasn’t helped anyone. It certainly has.

What I want, in the end, is modest. To keep a little distance when we see a perfectly structured story of pain: who posted it, who benefits from its visibility, and what happens next. And to remember that the person speaking and the framework around them are not the same thing.

Sources